IJTC
Ilomata International Journal of Social ScienceVolume 7, Issue 4, October 2026 · Original Research
Home / Vol. 7 No. 4 (2026) / Articles
Original Research

Global Media Narratives on the Gaza Flotilla as a Strategic Issue in Mass Communication

Amin Aminudin · SuwadiBudi Luhur University, Jakarta, Indonesia · Correspondence: [email protected]
Published31 October 2026
IssueVol. 7, Issue 4, pp. 1–10
Keywords
gaza flotillamultimodal narrative analysispublic diplomacystrategic narrativeconflict communicationglobal news media

Abstract

The 2025 Gaza flotilla missions became contested communicative events in which humanitarian, legal, and security claims competed for international legitimacy. Previous research on flotilla coverage has relied mainly on text-based analysis of the 2010 Mavi Marmara incident, and studies of Gaza news rarely compare narrative structure and visual design across outlets with different institutional models. This study compares how Al Jazeera English (AJE) and BBC News constructed the 2025 flotilla through textual and visual narratives, treats The New York Times (NYT) as an exploratory third case, and interprets the public-diplomacy meanings of those constructions. Using qualitative, critical-constructivist multimodal narrative analysis, we examined 33 news items (AJE = 23, BBC = 7, NYT = 3) published between 1 June and 31 October 2025, selected from 38 candidates. Claude Sonnet 5.5 (Anthropic), accessed through claude.ai, was used as an AI coding assistant to generate initial codes with supporting excerpts; both authors verified every code against the source text and made all final coding decisions. The analysis integrated Fisher’s narrative coherence and fidelity, Riessman’s structural narrative analysis, and Kress and van Leeuwen’s visual grammar. AJE framed the missions predominantly as humanitarian action obstructed by Israel (18 of 23 items), drew mainly on activist sources, and asserted illegality in its own voice in 7 items. The BBC structured every item around competing, attributed claims and reported Israeli officials’ dismissive labels while also qualifying the aid as “symbolic” or “token”. The limited NYT material foregrounded Israeli government statements and is reported as indicative only. The study proposes a Narrative Diplomacy Framework (narrative selection, multimodal legitimization, and diplomatic circulation) that treats news narratives as interpretive resources within public diplomacy, not as evidence of state control or audience effects.

Introduction

Humanitarian interventions in armed conflicts are contested not only at sea or on land but also in the news, where competing actors define who is a victim, who is a violator, and what counts as lawful action (Evans, 2010; Iqbal & Farukh, 2025). This article treats the 2025 Gaza flotilla as a communicative event: a humanitarian initiative that is also a narrative object around which organizers, governments, and news organizations construct meaning. Following Roselle et al. (2014), a strategic narrative is a means by which political actors construct shared meaning of past, present, and future to shape audiences’ behaviour.

The flotilla organizers (the Freedom Flotilla Coalition and the Global Sumud Flotilla), the Israeli government, and the states whose citizens were aboard all issued competing accounts of the missions. Transnational news outlets then selected, combined, and visualized these accounts for global audiences, which is why news coverage is a relevant site for studying public diplomacy (Gilboa, 2008; Nye, 2008).

Research on Israel–Palestine news shows that outlets differ systematically in the actors they quote, the labels they

apply, and the moral evaluations they imply. Evans (2010) compared The New York Times’ coverage of army sieges of two

Palestinian refugee camps and showed that similar events were framed very differently in both the volume of coverage

and the language used to describe actors. El Damanhoury et al. (2025) applied critical discourse analysis to Al Jazeera

English and BBC online reporting on the 2023 Gaza war and documented contrasting representations of Israeli and

Palestinian actors. Comparable contrasts have been reported between Kompas.id and the BBC (Putra, 2024) and among

Kompas.id, Republika, CNN, and Aljazeera.com in coverage of the 2024 Israel–Lebanon conflict (Ainani & Yudiansyah,

2025). Iqbal and Farukh (2025) further showed how metaphors encode ideological positions in conflict reporting,

and audience-oriented studies in Jordan indicate that humanitarian and moral narratives dominate digital

conversations on Gaza (Alsharairi et al., 2025). These studies establish that framing differences exist, but most analyse a

single mode (text), two outlets, or the 2023–2024 wars rather than humanitarian missions such as flotillas. Scholarship on earlier flotillas offers the closest

comparison. Research on the 2010 Mavi Marmara raid found that Israel’s account dominated English-language

international coverage, whereas Turkey’s account gained ground mainly in media from Muslim-majority countries

(Bayram, 2015). A content analysis of 156 online stories from Haaretz, The Guardian, and The New York Times found that

the three newspapers differed in their use of war- and peacejournalism frames (Fahmy & Eakin, 2014). Legal scholarship shows that the lawfulness of intercepting flotilla vessels under

the law of naval blockade is itself contested (Buchan, 2011). Studies of mediated public diplomacy show that transnational

broadcasters can carry foreign-policy meanings: Samuel-Azran (2013) analysed Al Jazeera within Qatar’s state-sponsored

media diplomacy, and Fahmy (2012) examined how Arab satellite news relates to audience perceptions. Entman’s

cascading activation model explains how elite frames may flow from governments to news media, while also showing that

journalists can contest them (Entman, 2003). However, this literature has focused mainly on textual frames and on the

2010 incident. The narrative and visual construction of the 2025 missions remains largely unexamined. A third stream of research addresses narrative and

multimodality. Public-diplomacy scholars increasingly argue that influence depends on the coherence and credibility of

narratives rather than on isolated messages (Hobbs et al., 2025; Roselle et al., 2014; Saliu, 2023), and strategic

narratives have been traced empirically across national information environments (Yanchenko & Humprecht, 2025).

In visual communication, Rodriguez and Dimitrova (2011) distinguish denotative, stylistic-semiotic, connotative, and

ideological levels of visual framing. Kress and van Leeuwen (2020) provide a grammar for analysing representational,

interactive, and compositional meanings, and Cheema et al. (2023) show that image–text relations shape the news values

of online stories. These tools have rarely been combined with structural narrative analysis to compare outlets reporting the

same humanitarian–security event. Taken together, prior studies leave three gaps. Empirically,

no study has compared how transnational outlets with different institutional models narrated the 2025 flotilla

missions. This study compares a state-funded transnational broadcaster (Al Jazeera English) with a public-service

broadcaster (BBC News). A commercial elite newspaper (The New York Times) is included as an exploratory case: only three

of its items met the inclusion criteria, all of them available only in paywall-truncated form, so it is used to examine whether the

two main patterns extend to a third institutional model, not as a full third comparison. Methodologically, research on flotilla

and Gaza coverage has relied mainly on textual framing or discourse analysis and has not explained how narrative roles and

visual design reinforce or contradict one another. Theoretically, public-diplomacy research has not specified the narrative

mechanisms through which news coverage turns a humanitarian event into a resource for international legitimacy. Accordingly,

this study aims to compare how Al Jazeera English and BBC News constructed the 2025 Gaza flotilla through textual and visual

narratives, to explore how the available NYT coverage relates to these patterns, and to explain how those constructions articulate

public-diplomacy meanings. It addresses three research questions. RQ1: How did AJE and BBC News construct the

narrative elements of the 2025 flotilla (setting, protagonists, antagonists, conflict, moral evaluation, and resolution), and how

does the available NYT material compare? RQ2: Which lexical, sourcing, and visual strategies did they use, and how did text and

image interact? RQ3: What public-diplomacy meanings can be interpreted from these constructions? Because the study

analyses media content, it does not measure audience reception or policy effects. Statements about public diplomacy are

therefore interpretive propositions grounded in the coded content, not claims about effects. Three theoretical resources guide the analysis. First, Fisher’s

narrative paradigm proposes that people judge stories by narrative probability (coherence) and narrative fidelity (Fisher,

1984). In this study, coherence was identified through structural coherence (a logically ordered sequence of events), material

coherence (consistency with facts acknowledged across outlets), and characterological coherence (consistent motives attributed

to actors). Fidelity was identified through explicit or implied “good reasons,” that is, appeals to humanitarian, legal, security, or

sovereignty values. Second, Riessman’s structural approach to narrative analysis (Riessman, 2008) organizes stories into

orientation, complicating action, evaluation, and resolution. We translated these into six narrative elements: setting,

protagonist/victim, antagonist, conflict, moral evaluation, and resolution. Third, Kress and van Leeuwen’s visual grammar

specifies representational (participants and actions), interactive (gaze, social distance, angle), and compositional (information

value, salience, framing) meanings (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2020). Strategic narrative theory (Roselle et al., 2014) connects

these levels to public diplomacy by treating the resulting stories as resources that actors can use to claim legitimacy. In short,

Fisher supplies the evaluative criteria, Riessman the structural units, and Kress and van Leeuwen the visual categories. The

three were integrated in a single codebook (Table 2).

Methods

This study adopts a qualitative, critical-constructivist design. It is constructivist because news narratives are treated as

constructions of reality rather than mirrors of events. It is critical because the analysis asks whose perspectives are amplified or

marginalized, and how narrative choices relate to unequal power between state and non-state actors (Entman, 2007). This critical

orientation shaped the coding of sourcing asymmetries and legal labels. However, interpretations were constrained by explicit

coding rules and by applying the same dimensions to all three outlets. Multimodal narrative analysis was chosen because the

research questions concern both narrative structure and the interaction of words and images (Cheema et al., 2023; Rodriguez

& Dimitrova, 2011). The design also incorporated an AI-assisted coding stage. Claude (Anthropic), a large language model

accessed through the claude.ai web interface, was used as a coding assistant, not as an independent coder: it applied the

codebook to the archived text of each item and returned candidate codes with supporting excerpts, which both authors

then verified (see Coding Framework). The interpretation, the development of higher-order categories, and the Narrative

Diplomacy Framework were carried out by the authors.

The three outlets were selected purposively as Englishlanguage transnational news organizations with distinct institutional models: Al Jazeera English (state-funded, Doha-

based), BBC News (public-service, London-based), and The New York Times (commercial, New York-based). The analysis

period ran from 1 June to 31 October 2025. It covers the departure of the Madleen (1 June 2025), the interception of

the Handala (26–27 July 2025), the voyage and interception of the Global Sumud Flotilla (31 August–3 October 2025), and

the subsequent detention and deportation coverage. Candidate items were identified on 1 November 2025, after

the end of the analysis period, through each outlet’s website search and site-restricted Google searches (e.g.,

site:aljazeera.com) using the keywords “flotilla,” “Gaza items that mentioned the flotilla only in passing. The search

identified 38 candidate items (AJE = 28, BBC = 7, NYT = 3). After full-text screening, 33 items were retained (AJE = 23, BBC = 7,

NYT = 3): two AJE items were excluded because the flotilla was a sub-item of wider Gaza coverage, two because they were video-

only, and one (A038) because it could not be archived (Table 1; Appendix A). The three NYT items could be retrieved only in

paywall-truncated form (headline, standfirst, and two to three opening paragraphs). In two of them (A021, A022), the lead

visual shown on the live page was not captured in the archived, paywall-truncated version. Because they met criterion (d) on the

live page, both items were retained, but their visual codes are reported as not codable (n.c.) in Tables 1 and 3. The NYT findings

are therefore reported separately and with caution, and the NYT

Table 1. Composition of the Analysed Corpus
Table 1. Composition of the Analysed Corpus (reproduced from source PDF)
Table 2. Codebook for Multimodal Narrative Analysis (part 1)
Table 2. Codebook for Multimodal Narrative Analysis (part 1) (reproduced from source PDF)

Coherence across outlets), and characterological (consistent motives) coherence. Label for the blockade or interception in

Lexis and sources Legal framing the outlet’s own voice: illegal / lawful / contested (attributed) / absent. Number, type, and order of quoted sources (activists, Israeli officials, third Sourcing states, UN/NGOs, legal experts); position of the first quoted source. Word in the outlet’s own voice that limits the scale or seriousness of the aid or mission (“symbolic,” “token,” “trying to Qualifier deliver”). Coded present/absent; uses in quotation marks are noted as possibly echoing a source. Delegitimizing label for the mission or its participants attributed to officials (e.g., Dismissive label “selfie yacht,” “publicity stunt,” (reported) “provocateurs,” alleged Hamas links). Coded present/absent. Statements or actions of third states, intergovernmental bodies, or Reported state participants’ home states reported in

Diplomatic context reactions the item (condemnation, support, consular action, criticism of the flotilla). Coded present/absent. Participants and actions depicted

Visual (Kress & van Representational (vessels, activists, soldiers, maps, Leeuwen) symbols such as flags). Gaze (demand/offer), social distance Interactive (close-up, medium, long shot), and angle. Information value (top/bottom, Compositional and left/right), salience, framing; source of provenance the image (outlet, agency, Israeli government, flotilla). Relation between the lead visual and the Text–image relation headline/lead: reinforcement, elaboration, or tension. described consistently “illegal blockade”; “lawful naval blockade,” attributed first source in lead paragraph a “token amount of aid” “selfie yacht,” attributed to Israel’s Foreign Ministry condemnation by a foreign ministry; Meloni’s criticism of the flotilla vessel with Palestinian flags long shot at eye level map at top; “AFP via Getty Images” sympathetic image under an attributive standfirst (elaboration)

Table 2. Codebook for Multimodal Narrative Analysis (continued)
Table 2. Codebook for Multimodal Narrative Analysis (continued) (reproduced from source PDF)

Coding proceeded in two stages. In the first stage, Claude Sonnet 5.5 (Anthropic, 2026), a large language model

accessed through the claude.ai web interface, was used as an AI coding assistant on 13 October 2026. It was given the

coding instrument (the instructions and the codebook reproduced in Supplementary File S1) and the archived PDF

of each candidate item (A001–A037). For each item it recorded the screening decision, assigned every narrative,

evaluative, lexical, sourcing, and visual code in the coding sheet, and quoted one to three supporting excerpts. Only

published journalistic texts were entered into the tool. In the second stage, both authors checked every screening decision,

code, and excerpt against the original article; corrections were recorded in the notes column of the coding sheet, and

disagreements were resolved through discussion. The code for reported state reactions, added during revision, was

assigned on 2 November 2026 with the same two-stage procedure (AI assistant: Claude, Anthropic), using the live

versions of the articles where they could be retrieved and the archived texts otherwise, and was checked by the authors.

The AI assistant was thus treated as a coding aid, not as an independent coder, and all final coding decisions are the

authors’ own. Because the design is qualitative, no inter-coder reliability coefficient was computed (see Trustworthiness,

Reflexivity, and Ethics). The analysis proceeded in five steps. (1) Each item was

coded by the AI coding assistant, with every code verified by both authors, for narrative, lexical, and sourcing features, and

its lead visual for representational, interactive, compositional, and provenance features. (2) Codes were entered into an

item-by-code matrix, from which the descriptive frequencies reported in the Results were derived. These frequencies are

used to show how widespread a pattern is, not to test hypotheses. (3) Text–image relations were classified as

reinforcement, elaboration, or tension. (4) Patterns were compared across outlets on the same dimensions, with

attention to negative cases that ran against the dominant pattern. (5) Higher-order categories were developed

abductively into the Narrative Diplomacy Framework (see Discussion). Consistent with the interpretive paradigm, rigour was

established through qualitative trustworthiness criteria rather than a statistical index of inter-coder reliability (Lincoln &

Guba, 1985). Credibility was supported by peer debriefing between the two authors on all interpretive categories and by

negative-case analysis, for example the BBC’s and AJE’s own use of “symbolic” to describe the aid. Dependability and

confirmability were supported by an audit trail: the archived PDFs, the codebook, the item-level coding sheet with

supporting excerpts (Supplementary File S1), which records the AI-generated codes and the authors’ corrections, and the

memos. Because an AI assistant can misread attribution or overlook implicit evaluation, no AI-generated code was

accepted without checking its supporting excerpt against the original article. Every interpretive claim in the Results is linked

to item identifiers listed in Appendix A. Transferability is supported by a detailed description of the corpus, period, and

context. As Indonesian communication scholars writing in a country whose foreign policy supports Palestinian statehood,

we acknowledge that our position may shape interpretation. We therefore applied identical codes to all outlets and

distinguished outlet wording from our own synthesis. The study analysed only publicly available, published

journalistic content and involved no human participants. Images are reproduced for critical analysis with source

attribution. Contested allegations reported in the coverage, such as claims of mistreatment in detention or of organizers’

links to Hamas, are analysed as narrative claims attributed to their sources, not as facts established by this study.

Result and Discussion

The 2025 Flotilla Missions as Communicative Events

The corpus covers three missions. The Madleen departed from Catania, Sicily, on 1 June 2025 with 12 people aboard,

including the climate activist Greta Thunberg and the MEP Rima Hassan, and was intercepted on 9 June in international

waters (A001, A002). In July, the Handala, carrying 21 activists from 10 countries, was intercepted on its approach to Gaza

(A006). The Global Sumud Flotilla left Barcelona on 31 August, was joined by boats from Tunisia and Italy, reported suspected

drone attacks off Tunisia on 8–9 September and off Crete on 23–24 September, and was intercepted from 1 October (A006,

A008, A010, A013, A027). According to AJE, the flotilla comprised at least 44 civilian boats carrying some 500

activists, with participants from 37 countries, including 30 from Spain, 22 from Italy, 21 from Turkiye, and 12 from Malaysia

(A027). Israel’s Foreign Ministry reported 461 detainees (A031), and the BBC reported about 470 arrests (A036). The first boats were boarded about 70 nautical miles from

Gaza and the last vessel, the Marinette, about 42.5 nautical miles away (A027, A036). The BBC stated that Israel “has been

policing this area but does not have jurisdiction there” (A036). Whether intercepting vessels in international waters is lawful

under the law of naval blockade is legally contested (Buchan, 2011). This study does not adjudicate that question. It analyses

how each outlet framed it. The three outlets, reporting on the same interceptions,

constructed systematically different narrative versions of them. Table 3 summarizes the frequencies. The following subsections

present representative evidence for each outlet; the patterns are interpreted in the Discussion. AJE constructed the flotilla predominantly as legitimate

humanitarian action obstructed by Israel. The conflict was defined as the obstruction of aid in 18 of 23 items, activists

were the topic actor in 22 and the narrative protagonists in 18 (Table 3), and moral evaluation drew on humanitarian and legal

values in 22. Headlines described the missions as attempts “to break Israeli siege” (A006) or to “break Gaza siege” (A008),

and reported reactions to the Madleen’s seizure under the headline “‘Piracy’” (A003). In its own voice, AJE asserted the

illegality of the blockade or the interceptions in 7 items, for example “Israel’s illegal blockade of the Strip” (A001), a boat

“illegally seized in international waters” (A002), and an explainer headlined “How Israel breaks international maritime

law,” which answered its own question about Israel’s right to board ships with “The answer is no” (A029). The label “illegal

blockade” itself appeared in AJE’s own voice in only 2 items (A001, A005). More often the blockade was called a “siege” or

“blockade” without qualification (18 items), while illegality claims were voiced by quoted sources. Contrary to a common

assumption, AJE did not use “Israeli Occupation Forces” in its own voice. That phrase appeared only in quotations from

activists (A028). AJE’s usual labels were “Israeli forces” (14 items) and “Israeli military” or “navy” (6). Mapped onto the codebook, the AJE narrative followed a

consistent arc. The setting was the Mediterranean high seas and a Gaza described as facing famine. The protagonists were

activists presented as a nonviolent transnational collective (A004, A009, A012). The antagonist was the Israeli state. The

resolution, reported in 11 items, was detention and deportation. Activists were the first quoted source in 15 items,

and activist testimony appeared in 17. Organizers described communications being jammed to block distress signals and

livestreams as the boats were boarded (A027). This sequence is structurally coherent in Fisher’s sense, with events unfolding

in a clear order and the actors’ motives remaining consistent (Fisher, 1984). Testimony was a central narrative device in the detention

coverage. AJE quoted David Adler, a US participant in the Global

Sumud Flotilla, as saying, “We were kidnapped, stripped, ziptied, blindfolded … and for the next five days … we were psychologically tortured” (A035). Other items reported

allegations that Thunberg was “dragged on the ground” and “forced to kiss the Israeli flag” (A032), and that detainees

were treated “like monkeys” (A033). These are allegations attributed to the activists. In A032 and A033, AJE also

reported the Israeli Foreign Ministry’s rejection of them as “complete lies” and “brazen lies,” together with Ben-Gvir’s

statement that he was “proud” of the harsh treatment (A033). Israeli officials were quoted or paraphrased in 12 of 23 AJE

items. Analytically, the testimony supplies first-person victims and moral stakes, while the quoted denials keep the narrative

formally two-sided. AJE linked the 2025 missions to earlier flotillas or to the

blockade in place since 2007 in 11 items, and published a dedicated map headlined “Israel has attacked, intercepted all

Gaza-bound flotillas since 2010” (A011). It also gave extensive space to state reactions, cataloguing

condemnations from more than a dozen governments and organizations (A003, A030). These reaction pieces also

included critical voices, such as Italian Prime Minister Meloni’s view that the flotilla brought “no benefit to the

Palestinian people” (A027, A030). The selection therefore shows which reactions AJE chose to amplify rather than

demonstrating an international consensus. A negative case is that AJE itself described the cargo as “symbolic humanitarian

aid” (A027) and the voyage as a “symbolic mission” (A002), a wording otherwise associated with skeptical framing. Visually, the AJE lead images were mostly photographs

(17 of 23), followed by videos (4) and maps or infographics (2). In 16, participants were shown at medium distance, and

12 were produced by AJE’s own journalists, including a reporter on board (A009, A012, A014). In Figure 1, the

representational meaning is carried by a route map whose vectors converge on Gaza and by an AFP photograph of a

moored vessel displaying Palestinian, Algerian, and Tunisian flags with the hand-painted slogan “Gaza we see u, we’re

coming.” The map occupies the upper part of the composition (the “ideal” position) and the photograph the lower (the “real”)

(Kress & van Leeuwen, 2020). Image and text reinforced each other in 20 of 23 items. Overall, AJE’s coverage was sympathetic to the flotilla and

critical of Israel’s actions, mainly through the selection of protagonists, sources, and historical context rather than

through legal labels in its own voice. This pattern corresponds with earlier research on Qatar’s media diplomacy (Samuel-

Azran, 2013). Funding alone, however, does not demonstrate that editorial content is directed by the state. This

correspondence is examined as an interpretive question in the Discussion.

BBC News: A Procedural-Balance Narrative

BBC News constructed every item in the corpus (7 of 7) around competing claims, and its moral evaluation was

procedural or mixed in all of them. Attribution was visible even in headlines: “Greta Thunberg deported, Israel says” (A015),

“Greta Thunberg’s Gaza flotilla hit by drones, organisers claim” (A019), and “Thunberg denies claims Gaza flotilla is a

publicity stunt” (A020). In each, the contested claim is assigned to a named party rather than asserted by the outlet.

The BBC called the blockade a “maritime” or “naval blockade” (2 items) or simply “blockade” (3), and attributed the phrases

“illegal siege” to organizers and “lawful naval blockade” to Israeli officials (A017, A036). Sourcing was balanced in presence but not in framing.

Israeli officials were quoted in all 7 BBC items, and activists in 6. The first quoted source was Israeli in 3 items and activist

in 4. All 7 items reported Israeli officials’ dismissive characterizations of the missions, such as “selfie yacht”

(A015, A016, A020), “publicity stunt” (A017–A020, A036), or “provocateurs” (A036). In 5 items, the BBC also qualified the

aid or the mission in its own voice: a “symbolic” amount of aid (A015, A016, A017), a “token amount of aid” (A020), or a

flotilla “trying to deliver aid” (A036). In A015 and A016 the word appears in quotation marks and may echo the organizers’ own

description. At the same time, the BBC used independent verification that cut against official accounts: BBC Verify

authenticated the drone-strike footage, and an analyst’s view that it “casts serious doubt on the Tunisian authorities’ version

of events” was reported (A019). The BBC also stated in its own voice that Israel lacks jurisdiction in the interception zone

(A036). Historical context appeared in 4 BBC items, through

references to the 2007 blockade (A015, A016) or the 2010 Mavi Marmara raid (A017, A019). Violence was mostly reported

in procedural terms of detention and deportation. Because the outlet seldom adjudicated between competing legal claims, its

coverage left the legality of the blockade largely open. Following Entman’s argument that the absence of evaluation can itself

have framing consequences (Entman, 2007), one

interpretation is that this ambiguity leaves the existing situation unchallenged. An alternative interpretation is that it reflects

professional norms of attribution when facts are disputed and independent access is restricted. The BBC Verify item (A019)

and the jurisdiction statement (A036) show that the BBC did intervene in its own voice where verification was possible. Visually, BBC lead visuals were mostly videos (5 of 7) and

long shots (4 of 7). The lead image in Figure 2 is an AFP/Getty photograph of a vessel in long shot, at eye level, against open

sea and sky. The activists are small and cannot be identified, and no participant addresses the viewer. In Kress and van

Leeuwen’s terms, this is an “offer” image at public social distance, which invites observation rather than identification

(Kress & van Leeuwen, 2020). Image and text were congruent in all 7 items, as both maintained emotional distance.

The New York Times: A Diplomatic-Skepticism Narrative (Exploratory Case)

(Exploratory Case Because only paywall-truncated text was available for the

three NYT items, the following observations are limited to headlines, standfirsts, and opening paragraphs, and they are

offered as an exploratory check on the two main patterns rather than as a third full case. Within these, the NYT foregrounded

Israeli government statements in all three items: “Israeli authorities called the voyage a public relations stunt” (A021),

“The Israelis have asked that the aid be given to them to distribute” (A022), and “The Israeli government said it had

detained activists who were trying to take humanitarian aid to the blockaded enclave” (A037). Like the BBC, the NYT

attributed contested claims in its headlines, as in “Aid Flotilla Headed for Gaza Says It’s Under Drone Attack” (A022). The NYT described the participants as “activists” or “a

protest group” (A022) and the Global Sumud mission as “widely publicized” (A037). It also gave background that Israel “has

imposed stringent restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid” and that the blockade “has been in place for nearly two

decades” (A037). No activist testimony appeared in the available text. Visually, the explainer reproduced in Figure 3

opens with a video still, taken at eye level and medium distance, of a flotilla vessel displaying Palestinian, Algerian, and

Tunisian flags (A037). The image is more sympathetic than the standfirst, so text and image stand in a relation of elaboration

rather than reinforcement. Table 3 compares the three outlets on the same coding

dimensions. Two distinct narrative versions are clearly supported by the data, and a third is indicated more tentatively.

In AJE, the flotilla was predominantly humanitarian action obstructed by Israel, told through activists’ voices and a history

of earlier flotillas. In the BBC, it was a disputed event in which every claim was attributed and Israeli and activist accounts

were reported side by side. In the limited NYT material, it was

“blockade” or “siege” without qualification, and all three described the cargo as symbolic at least once (AJE 3 items;

BBC 5; NYT 1). What differed was who was cast as protagonist, who spoke first, whether testimony was quoted,

and whether historical continuity was supplied. Here the distinction between topic actor and protagonist matters.

Activists were the topic actor of the headline or lead in almost every item (AJE 22 of 23; BBC 7 of 7; NYT 3 of 3), because the

flotilla was what the stories were about. Their role as narrative protagonist differed: AJE organized 18 of 23 items around the

activists’ obstructed mission, whereas all 7 BBC items and 2 of the 3 NYT items were structured as competing claims in

which activist and Israeli accounts shared the narrative. The third NYT item (A037) defined the conflict as obstructed aid

but introduced it through an Israeli government statement. Activists were the first source in 15 of 23 AJE items and 4 of

7 BBC items. Testimony appeared in 17 of 23 AJE items, 6 of 7 BBC items, and none of the available NYT text. Historical

context appeared in 11 of 23 AJE items and 4 of 7 BBC items. Legal framing was the clearest point of divergence. AJE

asserted illegality in its own voice in 7 of 23 items and quoted blockade is itself disputed (Buchan, 2011), these choices

matter. A narrative that treats the interception as illegal supports pressure to end the blockade, whereas one that treats

legality as contested leaves the existing situation in place. The visual dimension added a further layer to these differences.

AJE’s on-deck photographs and maps placed viewers close to the activists, often through its own reporter on board. The BBC’s

long-shot images and short videos kept viewers at a distance. The single NYT lead visual available showed the flotilla

sympathetically, in tension with its standfirst. Visual choices thus functioned as framing strategies that offer different

positions of identification to viewers (Rodriguez & Dimitrova, 2011). The findings extend prior research in three ways. First, they

show that the sourcing differences documented for the 2023 Gaza war (El Damanhoury et al., 2025) and for the 2010 flotilla

(Bayram, 2015; Fahmy & Eakin, 2014) also structure coverage of the 2025 missions. These differences operate at the level of

whole narrative arcs rather than isolated labels: the outlets used largely similar vocabulary for the blockade, but differed in

who was cast as protagonist, who spoke first, and which past

Table 3. Comparative Coding Summary of Narrative and Multimodal Dimensions
Table 3. Comparative Coding Summary of Narrative and Multimodal Dimensions (reproduced from source PDF)

was invoked. Second, consistent with Evans (2010), small lexical choices still mattered where they occurred. Qualifiers

such as “symbolic” or “token” aid, used most often by the BBC, weaken the fidelity of the humanitarian narrative in

Fisher’s sense (Fisher, 1984), because they question the good reasons the activists offer for acting. Third, the evidence allows the term “counter-hegemonic”

to be specified. We applied it only where three criteria were met: (a) the outlet challenged, in its own voice, the legal

account offered by the more powerful state actor; (b) it quoted activist testimony; and (c) image and text reinforced each

other. AJE met all three criteria in 4 of 23 items (A001, A002, A004, A031), the BBC in 1 of 7 (A036), and the NYT in none.

AJE’s alternative narrative therefore worked mainly through source selection, protagonist roles, and historical context

rather than through explicit legal assertion. Given that Israel’s account dominated English-language coverage of the 2010

flotilla (Bayram, 2015), this suggests that AJE’s coverage functioned as an alternative to the dominant account, though

in a more attributed and less declaratory form than is often assumed. The relation between these narratives and state positions

requires caution. The patterns correspond in part with known foreign-policy positions, and AJE’s pattern is consistent with

research on state-sponsored media diplomacy (SamuelAzran, 2013) and with the cascading of elite frames to the press (Entman, 2003). Content analysis, however, cannot

demonstrate state control, editorial intent, or coordination. Alternative explanations include professional sourcing

routines that favour accessible official sources; unequal access, since activists were detained and their

communications cut while Israeli authorities released footage; and diversity within each outlet, illustrated by the

BBC’s own verification work (A019). We therefore interpret the outlets’ narratives as discursive correspondences with

broader soft-power environments (Nye, 2008; Roselle et al., 2014), not as instruments of state diplomacy. Multimodally, the outlets differed less in whether they

used images than in how those images positioned viewers. AJE’s medium-distance, often self-produced images and the

BBC’s long shots show that social distance and provenance are part of the narrative contest (Rodriguez & Dimitrova,

2011). This extends the analysis of image–text relations (Cheema et al., 2023) by adding provenance and the

reporter’s physical position, on board or at a distance, as analytic dimensions.

The Narrative Diplomacy Framework

The Narrative Diplomacy Framework was derived abductively from the coding results (Figure 4). Each

component is built from codes defined in Table 2, and Figure 4 shows the code-to-component mapping. Codes for topic

actor, protagonist, antagonist, conflict, first source, and historical context (setting) clustered into a first component,

narrative selection: decisions about which actors, conflicts, and pasts become part of the story. Codes for legal framing,

moral evaluation, qualifiers, reported dismissive labels, text– image relations, and the representational and interactive

meanings of visuals clustered into a second component, multimodal legitimization: the alignment of words and images

to confer or withhold legitimacy. Codes for resolution, visual provenance, and reported state reactions clustered into a

third component, diplomatic circulation: the points at which a narrative connects to the positions of states and international

institutions. The framework differs from strategic narrative theory (Roselle et al., 2014), which centres on narratives

projected by states, by treating the news organization as the actor that selects and assembles competing narratives. It also

differs from mediated public diplomacy (Gilboa, 2008), which focuses on governments’ use of media, by specifying the

narrative and multimodal mechanisms that operate within the coverage itself. Diplomatic circulation also differs from Entman’s (2003)

cascading activation model. Cascading activation explains how frames move downward, from a national administration

through other elites to the news media and the public, and how far journalists resist that movement; its question is where a

frame comes from. Diplomatic circulation describes a more horizontal movement: the points at which a news narrative,

once assembled, connects to the positions of several states and international institutions at the same time, through

reported state reactions (AJE 12 of 23 items; BBC 3 of 7; none in the available NYT text), through the provenance of images

released by a government or by the flotilla, and through resolutions such as deportation that involve participants’ home

states. Its question is where a narrative can travel and whose diplomatic claims it can serve. The two are complementary: the

outlets’ reliance on Israeli government statements and footage can be read as cascading activation, whereas AJE’s cataloguing

of third-state reactions (A003, A030) is a form of diplomatic circulation. Three propositions follow for future testing. P1: The more a

news narrative casts humanitarian actors as protagonists and supplies historical continuity, the more interpretive resources it

offers to actors seeking to delegitimize a blockade. P2: When verbal legal labels and visual provenance converge, a

narrative’s legitimizing function is stronger than when the two modes diverge. P3: Narratives that link an event to great-power

diplomacy are more likely to recentre it around state interests than around humanitarian outcomes. These propositions

concern how narratives may offer interpretive frames through which audiences and policymakers understand events. Testing

their effects would require audience or policy data.

Figure 4. The Narrative Diplomacy Framework
Figure 4. The Narrative Diplomacy Framework (reproduced from source PDF)

Conclusion

This study compared how Al Jazeera English and BBC News constructed the 2025 Gaza flotilla, with The New York

Times as an exploratory case. Regarding RQ1, AJE cast activists as protagonists confronting an antagonist state and

defined the conflict as the obstruction of aid (18 of 23 items). The BBC structured all 7 of its items around competing,

attributed claims. The limited NYT material introduced the events primarily through Israeli government statements.

Regarding RQ2, the outlets differed less in their vocabulary for the blockade than in sourcing, testimony, historical context,

qualifiers such as “symbolic” aid, and the social distance of their images. Regarding RQ3, these constructions can be

interpreted as offering different public-diplomacy resources: AJE’s narrative supports challenges to the legitimacy of the

interceptions, while the BBC’s attributive narrative leaves the dispute open and reproduces Israeli officials’ dismissive

labels alongside activists’ claims. The study makes two contributions. Empirically and

methodologically, it provides a comparative, multimodal account of AJE and BBC coverage of the 2025 flotilla, with

exploratory NYT evidence, that links narrative roles, legal labels, sourcing, and visual design within a single codebook,

with every claim traceable to identified items (Appendix A; Supplementary File S1). Theoretically, it proposes the

Narrative Diplomacy Framework, which specifies three mechanisms (narrative selection, multimodal legitimization,

and diplomatic circulation) through which news coverage turns a humanitarian event into a resource for international

legitimacy. For public-diplomacy practitioners, including those of middle powers such as Indonesia that support Palestinian

statehood, the findings suggest that outlet-specific narrative logics need to be understood before humanitarian initiatives

are communicated to international audiences. The study has several limitations. The purposive corpus of

33 items is unevenly distributed (AJE 23, BBC 7, NYT 3), and the NYT items were available only in truncated form, so the

NYT findings are indicative only, and the study is best read as a two-outlet comparison with an exploratory third case. The

five-month period captures the 2025 missions but not their longer-term coverage, and non-English, regional, and social-

media sources are excluded. Candidate items were identified through outlet search engines and site-restricted Google

searches rather than a licensed news database such as Factiva or Nexis Uni, so retrieval may be incomplete, particularly for the

BBC and the NYT, and the texts were archived about a year after publication, so later edits to live pages cannot be ruled out.

Coding was AI-assisted, and although every code was reviewed by the researchers against the source text (see Coding

Framework), the interpretation remains partly subjective. Finally, no audience or policy data were collected, so the study

cannot claim effects on perceptions or diplomacy. Future research could obtain complete NYT coverage through a news

database, test the framework’s propositions across other conflicts, languages, and platforms, combine content analysis

with audience experiments, and interview journalists about the editorial processes behind the observed patterns.

Author’s Contribution Statement

Amin Aminudin conceptualized the study, designed the methodology and the codebook, curated the corpus, conducted

the formal analysis, developed the Narrative Diplomacy Framework, prepared the figures, wrote the original draft,

revised the manuscript, and served as corresponding author. Suwadi verified every screening decision, code, and supporting

excerpt against the original articles, contributed to the formal analysis and interpretation, and reviewed and edited the

manuscript. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Source of Funding Statements

This research was funded by an internal research grant from Universitas Budi Luhur through its Directorate of Research

and Community Service (DRPM). The funding institution had no role in the design of the study, the collection, analysis, or

interpretation of the data, or the preparation of the manuscript.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Universitas Budi Luhur, particularly the Faculty of Communication and Creative Design, for institutional

support during this research.

References

Ainani, M., & Yudiansyah, F. (2025). Beyond objectivity-bias dichotomy: Media framing as soft power mechanism in international conflict. Jurnal Kajian Jurnalisme, 9(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.24198/jkj.v9i1.59844

Alsharairi, A., Al-Souob, H. A.-R., AlQadi, M. F., & Shatnawi, S. M. (2025). Social media communication and framing of the Gaza conflict: Impact on public opinion. Journal of Intercultural Communication, 25(3), 73–82. https://doi.org/10.36923/jicc.v25i3.1153

Bayram, S. (2015). Whose story won? Public diplomacy and international news coverage of the 2010 Gaza Flotilla/Mavi Marmara raid. Uluslararası İlişkiler [International Relations], 12(45), 39–60. https://www.irjournal.com/issues/volume-12-number-045-2015/whose-story-wonpublic-diplomacy-and-international-news-coverage-of-the-2010-gazaflotillamavi-marmara-raid

Buchan, R. (2011). The international law of naval blockade and Israel’s interception of the Mavi Marmara. Netherlands International Law Review, 58(2), 209–241. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0165070X11200032

Cheema, G. S., Hakimov, S., Müller-Budack, E., Otto, C., Bateman, J. A., & Ewerth, R. (2023). Understanding image-text relations and news values for multimodal news analysis. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, 6, Article 1125533. https://doi.org/10.3389/frai.2023.1125533

Davies, A. (2025, October 4). Israel steps up deportations of flotilla activists. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c701y9de2dro

El Damanhoury, K., Saleh, F., & Lebovic, M. (2025). Covering the Israeli– Palestinian conflict: A critical discourse analysis of Al Jazeera English and BBC’s online reporting on the 2023 Gaza war. Journalism and Media, 6(1), Article 9. https://doi.org/10.3390/journalmedia6010009

Entman, R. M. (2003). Cascading activation: Contesting the White House’s frame after 9/11. Political Communication, 20(4), 415–432. https://doi.org/10.1080/10584600390244176

Entman, R. M. (2007). Framing bias: Media in the distribution of power. Journal of Communication, 57(1), 163–173. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.14602466.2006.00336.x

Evans, M. (2010). Framing international conflicts: Media coverage of fighting in the Middle East. International Journal of Media & Cultural Politics, 6(2), 209–233. https://doi.org/10.1386/mcp.6.2.209_1

Fahmy, S. (2012). Mediated public diplomacy: Satellite TV news in the Arab world and perception effects. International Communication Gazette, 74(8), 728–749. https://doi.org/10.1177/1748048512459144

Fahmy, S., & Eakin, B. (2014). High drama on the high seas: Peace versus war journalism framing of an Israeli/Palestinian-related incident. International Communication Gazette, 76(1), 86–105. https://doi.org/10.1177/1748048513504046

Fisher, W. R. (1984). Narration as a human communication paradigm: The case of public moral argument. Communication Monographs, 51(1), 1–22. https://doi.org/10.1080/03637758409390180

Gilboa, E. (2008). Searching for a theory of public diplomacy. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 616(1), 55–77. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716207312142

Hobbs, M., Li, M., Huang, Z. A., & Desmoulins, L. (2025). Storytelling and grand strategy in public diplomacy: A case study of the speeches of President Xi Jinping. Public Relations Review, 51(4), Article 102594. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2025.102594

Iqbal, S., & Farukh, A. (2025). Framing narratives: Media representation of metaphors and ideologies in Israel-Palestine conflict. Cogent Arts & Humanities, 12(1), Article 2564883. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2025.2564883

Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (2020). Reading images: The grammar of visual design (3rd ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003099857

Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Sage.

Livni, E. (2025, October 1). Israel intercepted the flotilla headed to Gaza: What to know. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/01/world/middleeast/gazaflotilla-aid-global-sumud-israel.html

Melimopoulos, E. (2025, October 1). Israel intercepts last Gaza Sumud flotilla vessel: What we know so far. Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/10/1/israel-intercepts-gazasumud-flotilla-vessels-what-we-know-so-far

Nye, J. S. (2008). Public diplomacy and soft power. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 616(1), 94–109. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716207311699

Putra, A. (2024). Narrative discourse of the Israel-Palestine issue in the framework of political communication: A comparative study of Kompas.id and BBC media. Islamic Communication Journal, 9(2), 325–340. https://doi.org/10.21580/icj.2024.9.2.25845

Riessman, C. K. (2008). Narrative methods for the human sciences. Sage.

Rodriguez, L., & Dimitrova, D. V. (2011). The levels of visual framing. Journal of Visual Literacy, 30(1), 48–65. https://doi.org/10.1080/23796529.2011.11674684

Roselle, L., Miskimmon, A., & O’Loughlin, B. (2014). Strategic narrative: A new means to understand soft power. Media, War & Conflict, 7(1), 70–84. https://doi.org/10.1177/1750635213516696

Saliu, H. (2023). Narratives of public diplomacy in the post-truth era: The decline of soft power. Communication & Society, 36(2), 209–224. https://doi.org/10.15581/003.36.2.209-224

Samuel-Azran, T. (2013). Al-Jazeera, Qatar, and new tactics in state-sponsored media diplomacy. American Behavioral Scientist, 57(9), 1293–1311. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764213487736

Yanchenko, K., & Humprecht, E. (2025). Strategic narratives on social media: How information environments shape the Russian-Ukrainian War discourse in seven European countries. International Journal of Communication, 19. https://ijoc.org/index.php/ijoc/article/view/25136/5085